“Congrats on Saying the Biggest Number…”: Prison Policymaking in Ireland

This Isn’t a Debate

Political debate on whether we need a larger prison system in Ireland is over. The question of “should we build more prison spaces?” has been emphatically replaced by “how many should we build?” Criminal justice policymaking has been simplified to saying the biggest number as often as possible, without any consideration for existing harms and future risks.

The current Minister for Justice, Jim O’Callaghan, from Fianna Fáil is currently spearheading a prison building programme, committed to an additional 1,500 spaces by 2031. In a speech at the recent Fine Gael Ard Fheis, Simon Harris, a former Minister for Justice and Taoiseach-in-waiting, stated unequivocally that “[t]here must be more prison capacity.” Even the main opposition party have fallen into line on this position as Matt Carthy, Justice spokesperson from Sinn Féin, noted that “there is an immediate need to deliver additional prison spaces.”

In a recent opinion poll, these three large parties with clearly stated expansionist positions have a 58% of the electoral preference. If other parties of the right—Aontú and Independent Ireland—and the Independent bloc, which naturally skew to law and order positions, are also included, than 81% of the electorate are represented by penal expansionist politics and positions. Despite a self-understanding as a modern, progressive Republic, there exists an incredibly homogeneity on the need for more institutions of punishment.

Two Law and Order Parties

In the days preceding the Fine Gael Ard Fheis, trusted media attempted to create some intrigue or, at least, tepid public interest by wondering about whether Fine Gael had a discernible identity after 15 years in Government. Other commentators proposed coalescing around a Christian democratic or a firm “centre-right” position. When the speech was finally delivered, it was as expected with significant acknowledgment of “rural” Ireland, farmers, and business owners, while addressing law and order concerns, reassuring retirees, and undermining income support for unemployed people. So much for a rebranding.

More and more, whether by design or mere proximity, significant parts of Irish politics reflect the debates and policymaking in Westminister. Only a few days after Simon Harris’ unrestrained broadside on people who are in receipt of long-term welfare support (see here for excellent rebuttal of Fine Gael’s demonisation of this marginalised group), Kemi Badenoch sought to energise her Tory base with proposals for swingeing welfare cuts and inevitable enforced poverty.

As Simon Harris got into the law and order section of his Ard Fheis speech, he began with “Fine Gael is and always will be the party of Law & Order” [emphasis in original]. I began to question whether this is still true or not. Despite something being said regularly, it doesn’t make it so. Interestingly, his endorsement of the current prison building plan (1,500 spaces) was out of step with some of the party base; a motion from a South Dublin branch sought a commitment for a 50% increase in current prison capacity, an unimaginable 2,400 more spaces.

In the current Government, Ireland actually has two law and order parties. And likely will for decades to come under the Grand Coalition.

In many ways, this reflects the emergence of both Labour and the Conservatives as law and order parties in the UK. While, like Fine Gael, the common assumption is that the Conservatives are responsible for prison expansion. This is only partly true. When  New Labour, rebranded under Tony Blair, came to power in 1997, they inherited a prison system which had expanded rapidly under John Major to have 61,000 prison places. Taking over the baton, three successive Labour Governments added almost 25,000 places to a total of nearly 85,000 places by 2010 when they left office and David Cameron took over.

While it is unclear whether Jim O’Callaghan will remain as Minister for Justice when Simon Harris takes over as Taoiseach in November next year, his current tenure has borne striking hallmarks of his Fianna Fáil predecessor, John O’Donoghue. In his five-year spell as Minister for Justice from 1997 to 2002, O’Donoghue opened three prisons. In 1999, he opened Mountjoy Female prison with 105 spaces and Cloverhill prison with 430 spaces. Only a year later, he cut the ribbon on the Midlands prison with capacity for 515 people. Aside from extensions and refurbishments, and despite not quite achieving “radical plans for 2,000 additional prison spaces,” O’Donoghue created well over 1,000 new spaces when the prison population was much lower overall. Now O’Callaghan is embarking on a similar binge of prison building. But whoever takes over as Minister, regardless of party, they will continue on this trajectory.

What is clear, both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael are both law and order parties and they are both deeply committed to prison expansion.

It’s An Arms Race

So, what can we expect in the future? There will be a coarsening of political discourse in relation to prisons and incarcerated people. The “respectable” language of rehabilitation and reintegration will be exchanged for calls for longer punishment and permanent societal exclusion by leveraging key, emotive cases in the public eye.

Trading in the comfortable language of supply and demand logics, Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil will argue for continuous growth in prison capacity, with subtle knowing nods to population growth and inward migration.

Rather than restraint in language, both parties will seek to outdo each other in order to prove their law and order credentials to the increasingly footloose middle-class electorate. With little discernible policy differences, this effort to highlight distinctions will manifest in who can say the biggest number before elections. On a faintly positive note, actual delivery is secondary to the campaigning as the public move on to the material concerns of daily life.

The most concerning consequence of a prison arms race is that there is no end point. No point where a political party can say that we have a large enough prison system, or even that we need to begin to remove the most inhumane prison wings and landings. This is the inevitable consequence of political opportunism and and politicans with no vision for Ireland beyond a five-year electoral cycle. Political leadership has to demonstrate restraint and the boldness to say when enough is enough in relation to punishment by the State.

With the battle over, only in-fighting remains as to whether Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil can say the biggest number.

THREADS
BLUESKY