• Climate Strikers Want A Just Transition

    jcfj web just transitionThe Global Climate Strikes that take place this Friday (20th September) are about demanding that climate breakdown be addressed with the urgency it requires by governments. Part of this process is engaging with, and moving towards, a just transition to a low carbon economy.

    Read more

  • Homily Notes for Climate Protests

    ClimateStrike web jcfjAs our approach to the climate emergency is informed by Laudato Si', our Social Theologian Kevin Hargaden has created Homily Notes to be used in church to accompany the day's readings, or by lay persons as a reflection for prayer.

    Read more

  • Why I'm Striking for Climate Action

    climate web jcfjOn Friday, September 20th, there will be a Global Climate Strike, a protest led by school students who are calling on everyone to make their voice heard and demand action on the climate emergency. Ciara Murphy is joining them.

    Read more

  • Retrofit Government Priorities

    web retrofit jcfjHundreds of homeowners have been left high and dry by the SEAI retrofit scheme. Kevin Hargaden asks if the Government is really as invested in climate breakdown mitigation as it should be?

    Read more

About the Centre

The Jesuit Centre for Faith and Justice works to combat injustice and marginalisation in Irish society, through social analysis, education and advocacy.

The Centre highlights complex social issues, informs opinion and advocates for governmental policy change to create a fair and equitable society for all.

Analysis on our Key Issues

People in prison are amongst the most marginalised and vulnerable in our society. The majority have left school early, experience literacy and learning difficulties and have a history of unemployment... Click here to view all of our material on Penal Policy

Environmental protection has emerged as a key element of social justice debates in recent decades... Click here to view all of our material on Environmental Justice

The right to a safe and secure place to live is one of the most basic human rights, it is fundamental to enable people to live a dignified life... Click here to view all of our material on Housing Policy

In our political discourse, every question of human flourishing seems to be reduced to bottom-line thinking. This focus on riches impoverishes our shared discourse and has serious negative consequences for society Click here to view material on Economic Justice

The Jesuit Centre for Faith and Justice focuses on a number of other issues... Explore all here

Our Journal

wn420

Exploring Social Justice

Why Care - Social Justice Awareness for Younger People

Homelessness Figures Exceed 10,000

housing web jcfjThe latest figures for homelessness in Ireland have been published and for the first time the numbers counted are above 10,000. With over 3,700 children without a home, and the numbers of homeless families still growing, there is widespread dismay at the government’s failure to meaningfully respond to this long-running crisis, says Kevin Hargaden.

Minister for Housing, Eoghan Murphy addressed these figures on RTÉ Radio 1’s Morning Ireland programme this morning. In an interview conducted in masterful fashion by Bryan Dobson, the Minister was challenged on how even these alarming numbers do not come close to the full scale of the problem, as well as on how families are being evicted into homelessness, and how even with the positive talk of government policy making a difference, last year Dublin City Council only built 74 houses.

This final point appeared to raise the Minister’s hackles. He repeatedly tried to reframe the situation by bundling social housing in with public housing and deployed the dreaded i-word to characterise Dobson’s point. It was “an ideological point” to highlight this shocking fact. Dobson responded by asking on at least four separate occasions to clarify, “How many houses did Dublin City Council directly build itself last year?”

It is indeed true that the local government of the nation’s capital managed to build only 74 houses last year. It is also true, as Murphy insisted, that approximately 1,700 housing units were brought into the system through a range of mechanisms. His rebuttal in the interview suggested that people who were on the waiting list would not care how, exactly, a home was provided. On a superficial level, this is unobjectionable, but a more critical perspective might conclude that the Minister was effectively saying that people on housing lists had no other choice but to take what they are given.

This is the real ideological point being made. The government response to the housing crisis is called Rebuilding Ireland. It is so committed to the idea that housing should be provided by the market that it has resulted in a situation where we pay almost €2 million a day in subsidies to private landlords through schemes like “HAP”, money which could be invested in building public housing which would serve the common good as an asset for the State, dampen the market enthusiasm, and arguably provide more and better housing facilities to those currently homeless.

In a widely shared analysis of the policy published in Issue 80 of Working Notes, Margaret Burns, PJ Drudy, Rory Hearne and Peter McVerry are clear in where the ideology is to be found: “Ireland’s housing system and the current housing crisis are the result of policy choices, and of the political and ideological interests being served by those choices.”

There remains a housing crisis in Ireland, which is so clearly the product of an ideological commitment to distribute goods that are essential for human flourishing – housing – through inappropriate market mechanisms. Until the current government recognises that their blind faith in markets as a catch-all solution for all social problems is misplaced, the profound human harm hidden behind these figures will continue.

The desire for high-quality public-housing built in sufficient numbers to adapt to a changing society is not ideological. It is the coherent, compelling social policy which is in continuity with commitments present since the founding of the State. It is time to renovate Rebuilding Ireland from the ground up and develop an approach to housing that is fit for the 21st Century.

Posted in Housing & Homelessness News

Tags: Homelessness, Housing Crisis, Housing

Print Email